I am surprised how open everyone is to this kid playing here and how resigned people are to "he paid his debt". Moreover, I don't really care if the petition is signed by students or other members of the YSU community (including alumni). We all want to be proud of our institution and team as a representative of the larger YSU community. It is hard to be proud of welcoming this person on the team.
It may be a delicate situation, but there is certainly a significant level of tone deafness here between issues of rape culture on college campuses and, quite frankly, college football in general. To me, there is much more to this than, "people make mistakes".