Author Topic: Scalzo's Views  (Read 4492 times)

Offline SoupCity

  • King Penguin
  • ****
  • Posts: 335
    • View Profile
Scalzo's Views
« on: March 24, 2014, 08:22:33 AM »
Here is my position-by-position look at YSU’s roster heading into spring practice. Departed players have used up eligibility, unless noted:

OFFENSE

Quarterback

Who’s gone: Kurt Hess.

Who’s back: Senior Dante Nania, sophomore Tanner Garry, sophomore Nick Wargo, redshirt freshman Ricky Davis.

Scouting report: For the first time since 2010, there is uncertainty at this position. Nania (21 attempts) and Garry (10) are the only ones who have thrown a collegiate pass and neither has looked like a future standout in practice or in games. Davis is the talented wild card, but he spent all of last season on the practice squad. Is the fall starter on the current roster? YSU will use this spring to find out.

Running back

Who’s gone: Torrian Pace, Adaris Bellamy, John Medina (left team)

Who’s back: Senior Parnell Taylor (sitting out spring - injured), junior Demond Hymes, sophomore Jody Webb, sophomore Martin Ruiz, redshirt freshman Ryan Mosora, redshirt freshman Edmund Jacobs.
Who’s new: Freshman Ryan Moore, freshman Sidney Sandidge.

Scouting report: The deepest and most talented group on YSU’s roster. Ruiz ran for 1,100 yards and 15 TDs last fall, rewriting YSU’s freshman record book. Webb is a hold-your-breath blend of speed, vision and balance. Injuries robbed Hymes of his starting job last fall but he could start for half the conference. Moore and Sandidge were 2014 recruits who enrolled in January.

Tight end

Who’s gone: Carson Sharbaugh, Corey Henry (left team).

Who’s back: Senior Nate Adams, senior Kintrell Disher (sitting out spring - injured), sophomore Jacob Wood.

Who’s new: freshman Kevin Rader.

Scouting report: Sharbaugh played a lot of fullback last fall, so this unit returns pretty much intact. Adams is an underrated weapon as a receiver and Disher was starting to live up to his considerable potential before tearing his ACL at midseason. Wood was too good to redshirt last year and has breakout potential this fall.

Wide receiver

Who’s gone: Kevin Watts, Justin Getz (left team).

Who’s back: Senior Jelani Berassa, senior Christian Bryan, junior Andre Stubbs, junior Andrew Williams, junior Michael Wheary, junior Marcel Caver, junior Edward Killingsworth, redshirt freshman Derrick Burgess, redshirt freshman Anthony Marchionda, redshirt freshman Brad Good.

Scouting report: Stubbs had more than 1,000 yards between receptions, rushes and kick returns, but there’s not a clear-cut No. 1. Still, it’s a position of strength.

Offensive line

Who’s gone: C Chris Elkins, G Fred Herdman, T Kyle Bryant, T Andrew Sinko, C Mason Giacomelli (left team), G Dylan Greenberg.

Who’s back: Senior G Dana Harris, senior C Stephen Page, junior T Trevor Strickland, sophomore G Brock Eisenhuth, sophomore T Christian Wilson, sophomore T Dylan Colucci, sophomore G Matt Bell, sophomore G Jim Bertovich, redshirt freshman G Anthony Parente, redshirt freshman T Justin Spencer, redshirt freshman G Cole Newsome, redshirt freshman G Jacob Griffith.

Scouting report: Elkins, Herdman and Sinko started every game and Bryant started all but two, so this unit is losing a lot of experience. But YSU’s coaches are bullish on the younger players’ potential. Eisenhuth (who started the first eight games before getting hurt) and Strickland (five starts at two tackle spots) saw significant action last fall and will be counted on to provide leadership.

DEFENSE

Defensive line

Who’s gone: DT D.J. Moss, DE Kyle Sirl.

Who’s back: Senior DT Octavius Brown, senior DE Vince Coleman, senior DE Desmond Williams, junior DT Emmanuel Kromah, junior DT Steve Zaborsky, junior DE Eric Myers, junior DE Terrell Williams, sophomore DT Joshmere Dawson, sophomore DE Chavien Nolcox, sophomore DE Derek Rivers, sophomore DT Rickey Hagood II, redshirt freshman DE DaShawn Scott, redshirt freshman DE Fazson Chapman.

Scouting report: Sirl was the most productive player on an underachieving unit last fall. With most players returning, YSU’s coaches are hoping for more production this fall.

Linebacker

Who’s gone: Ali Cheaib, Dom Rich, Teven Williams (kicked off team).

Who’s back: Senior Travis Williams, junior Kevon Caffey, junior Dubem Nwadiogbu, junior Terry Johnson, sophomore Jaylin Kelly, sophomore B.J. Welch, sophomore Tyler Carter, sophomore Antoine Cox, redshirt freshman Cole Kochman, redshirt freshman Rhamir Thomas, redshirt freshman Mike Palumbo.

Scouting report: Losing Teven Williams hurts — he led the team in tackles each of the last three years — but Travis Williams has 28 career starts and Caffey started six games last fall, so there’s experience here. Kelly will get the first shot at replacing Teven.

Defensive back

Who’s gone: CB Dale Peterman, S Josh Garner, CB DeVon McKoy (left team), CB David Rivers (left team), SS Derek Sulick (left team), CB Jamarious Boatwright (quit — injury).

Who’s back: Senior CB Julius Childs, senior S Donald D’Alesio (sitting out spring with shoulder injury), junior S Tre’ Moore, sophomore CB Deion Hall, sophomore S Jameel Smith, sophomore S Kenny Bishop, sophomore CB Eric Thompson, redshirt freshman FS Grant Mercer, redshirt freshman CB Damarius Brinson Jr., redshirt freshman Kevin Cylar, redshirt freshman Ian Banks-Tillman.

Scouting report: Losing Peterman hurts — he may have been the team’s best defensive player last fall — but, honestly, when you give up as many passing yards as the Penguins did last fall, that’s not your biggest problem. D’Alesio will sit out the spring after having shoulder surgery, which gives YSU a chance to build some depth and look at some of the younger guys.

SPECIAL TEAMS

Who’s gone: P Nick Liste

Who’s back: Senior K Joey Cejudo, senior LS Nathan Gibbs, redshirt freshman K Connor McFadden.

Scouting report: Cejudo will handle punting and kicking this spring. Jamie Bryant turned this unit into one the league’s best last fall, but switched to defensive coordinator in the offseason. Safeties coach Mike Zordich and WR coach Kenny Carter will try to maintain the high standard.

Offline SoupCity

  • King Penguin
  • ****
  • Posts: 335
    • View Profile
Re: Scalzo's Views
« Reply #1 on: March 24, 2014, 08:23:31 AM »
Is it just me or do we lose an awful lot of players with Wolford?  Do other schools lose multiple players every year?  This really bothers me for some reason.

Offline ScarletRook

  • King Penguin
  • ****
  • Posts: 360
    • View Profile
Re: Scalzo's Views
« Reply #2 on: March 24, 2014, 09:46:48 AM »
I think the players we lost have been three fold:  academics, injuries and disciplinary actions.
If I recall, Mason Giacomelli is an engineering student (of which YSU football has several) and that is
a full plate just for academics alone.  Some players sustained injuries over the years that have been in their best health interest to step down.  Then there are those players who just can't follow the rules and become a cancer to the team.  Unfortunately, some of them are the top-notch players.

I have no problem with the coaching staff keeping personal decisions quiet.

Offline IAA Fan

  • Administrator
  • Emperor Penguin
  • *****
  • Posts: 12025
  • Bring Coke back to YSU!!
    • View Profile
    • ysupenguins.com
Re: Scalzo's Views
« Reply #3 on: March 24, 2014, 11:35:13 AM »
I think Soup and Scarlet both make valid points on players leaving. Some thoughts:

1. We just saw our last class of Heacock players leave. So, we should should not have players leaving because of staff differences ...outside of position changes.

2. I think Wolf does pull in some "fringe" players to try an beef-up the talent level. So we are naturally going to see more attrition among these types of players.

3. Coach Montgomery's offense is very difficult ...I think it would be an outstanding offense for an NFL team ...but is going to cause some difficulties at the collegiate level. However he has seemed to have adapted well.

4. Wolf simply recruits too many athletes, as opposed to football players. I think this, combined with #3, are why we have heard so much talk about "dumbing down" the plays this year. I am happy to see our new DC saying the same thing, as this is still a smash-mouth conference and none of the Dakotas played "smarter" football than YSU ...they simply played "tougher" football than the Guins.


Good article by Scalzo.

QB: I still hold a certain level of confidence here. I think we will miss the leadership and passing of Hess, but all of these new guys add a new element ...running. Hess Could really get away and complete a pass; yet, those few time he decided to run saw quite a bit of success. Now just imagine a true runner back there?

RB: Scalzo is right on here, but he does not touch heavily enough on the loss of Sharbaugh. It is clear that we are just crying for a big back.

TE: I fear Disher will need every bit of spring and summer ...even then he may still need another year. We need a #2 to step up and be noticed. Don't overlook Sharbaugh's blocking and setting skills ...this will be missed.

OL: Lots of bodies, I hope this develops into something.

WR: Loaded. Just what the doctor ordered for new QB.

DL: I like Scalzo's comments here ...very diplomatic way of saying you were run over last year. The talent here is fantastic ...losses are minimal. Most depth on the team.

LB: Somehow I forgot that Ali was a senior. Does not seem like he played 4-years. Coaches said that Tevin Williams is still on the team ...but added he has grade issues which will will still put him elsewhere this fall.

DB: Another position where losses have really hurt us. Peterman was the most underrated player we had last year. Boatwright & D’Alesio cannot be counted on to remain healthy ...the two of these guys are just so banged up. I did not know Boatwright had left the team. I have always loved Childs, factor is D'Alesio for a while and his true leadership capabilities (sure fire bet for captain in 2014). Thompson will be solid and I hear Banks-Tillman is the "real deal". Now factor in the hopefully increased pressure and these guys could be going places.

Special teams: Scalzo nailed this one ...coaching change leaves a lot of questions. Factor in the loss of List as the best punter in the conference last year. Cejudo will be pulling double-duty and the young McFadden has to strap on the big-boy shoes in 2014. Gibbs coming back is a blessing. I will not comment on the coverage until spring game when we see something.


Offline ysufan0505

  • Emperor Penguin
  • *****
  • Posts: 2477
    • View Profile
Re: Scalzo's Views
« Reply #4 on: March 24, 2014, 12:09:15 PM »
We will be fine. Go Guins