This is from Scalzo's Penguin Insider blog on Vindy.com. I believe he makes some good points in here.
Before I talk about the win over Butler, I want to start with this score from Saturday: Indiana State 27, Ball State 20.
Earlier in the week, YSU athletic director Ron Strollo explained why the Penguins scheduled three weak home games, including one against the non-scholarship Bulldogs. And I get it. Running an athletic department isn't cheap and, like most schools, YSU needs football to pay the bills.
But I also think it's short-sighted. Unlike most schools in the Missouri Valley, the Penguins play in a MAC-obsessed state. Beating a team like Ball State may cost YSU a little money in the short-term, but not only does it give your playoff hopes a boost, it gets people talking about Youngstown State football. And trust me, as someone who writes about YSU football for a living, there's not enough of that happening in Youngstown.
Maybe the Penguins' accountants wouldn't trade the Butler game for Ball State, but I think they're the only ones.
Saturday's crowd wasn't bad — there were 14,381 tickets distributed, although I'd guess they probably had half that number in the stands — but nobody was there because they thought it would be a great game. They were there because they like watching YSU football.
I think these games do long-term damage, because I think many fans can (and do) start to resent having to watch blowouts just so YSU can balance its budget. Maybe a game at Akron or Kent doesn't make as much sense financially, but the fans (and, yes, the media) would love it.
It also doesn't help that YSU's home conference schedule stinks. The Penguins play North Dakota State and South Dakota State on the road and don't play Northern Iowa at all. (UNI is off YSU's schedule this year and next year.) That leaves Western Illinois, Southern Illinois, South Dakota and Indiana State.
One more point: If YSU had won more conference game in each of the last three seasons, this whole discussion is moot. Nobody would care. The frustration over YSU's playoff drought is spilling over into everything else.
But as I wrote earlier this week, YSU is one of just two MVFC teams not to play at least one full-scholarship FCS team in its non-conference schedule. And the other one, Western Illinois, is playing two Big Ten teams.
the breakdown of MVFC non-conference games:
Illinois State (only three games, all full-scholarship FCS)
Mississippi Valley State: SWAC
Eastern Illinois: OVC
Austin Peay: OVC
Indiana State (two FBS, two full-scholarship FCS)
Indiana: Big Ten
Tennessee Tech: OVC
Ball State: MAC
Liberty: Big South
Missouri State (one FBS, three full-scholarship FCS)
Northwestern State: Southland
Oklahoma State: Big 12
North Dakota: Big Sky
Central Arkansas: Southland
North Dakota State (one FBS, three full-scholarship FCS)
Iowa State: Big 12
Weber State: Big Sky
Incarnate Word: Southland
Montana: Big Sky
UNI (two FBS, two full-scholarship FCS)
Iowa: Big Ten
Hawaii: Mountain West
Northern Colorado: Big Sky
Tennessee Tech: OVC
South Dakota (one FBS, two full-scholarship FCS, one NAIA)
Oregon: PAC-12
William Penn: NAIA
Montana: Big Sky
Northern Arizona: Big Sky
South Dakota State (one FBS, two full-scholarship FCS, one Division III)
Missouri: SEC
Cal Poly: Big Sky
Southern Utah: Big Sky
Wis.-Oshkosh: Division III
Southern Illinois (one FBS, two full-scholarship FCS, one NAIA)
Taylor: NAIA
Eastern Illinois: OVC
SE Missouri State: OVC
Purdue: Big Ten
Western Illinois (two FBS, two non-scholarship FCS)
Valparaiso: Pioneer
Wisconsin: Big Ten
Drake: Pioneer
Northwestern: Big Ten